The sweet older lady who kept the books for the church held out a check. “Here’s your bonus, Pastor Geoff.”
My bonus? I had only been the pastor for a month, and there were about 30 attenders. How could there be a bonus?
Not that we couldn’t use some cash. I had taken a steep pay cut when I left my job as a youth pastor to lead this tiny church outside of Houston. Sherry was working as a schoolteacher, and our combined salaries barely paid the bills. This bonus might take some pressure off while we figured out our new economic situation.
“How did I earn a bonus?”
“Our previous pastor set up the bonus system. Whatever money is in the bank at the end of the month is split 50/50 between the pastor and the church. This is your half of what’s in the bank this month.”
My heart sank a little. I now understood why the building was in such bad shape. Every dime spent on upkeep cut into the pastor’s monthly bonus, so he had deferred all maintenance while pocketing the cash. I never met the previous pastor, so I can’t judge his character. It did feel a little unethical, however.
I was torn over the ethics of accepting this bonus. Sure, a leader with less character could abuse the system, but I had a strong moral compass. While the bonus system was unique, wasn’t it really just another way to structure a pastor’s compensation? It wasn’t a big deal.
Although I’ve made ethical mistakes in the 30 years since that day, I didn’t take the bonus. Looking back, I don’t think the check itself was the real issue. The real issue was the kind of person that decision would begin to shape. Character erodes quietly, one small decision at a time. Our choices shape our character.
When Jesus was led by the Spirit into the desert, his character was being revealed. Satan began his temptation with what seemed like a reasonable choice, a gentle nudge in the wrong direction. Jesus was hungry. Although no one would blame him for turning stones into bread, no one would know. This simple miracle, however, would not reflect Jesus as the Son of God.
Eugene Peterson said in a letter to his son, another pastor, that the primary problem for the Christian leader is to take responsibility not just for the ends but also for the “ways and means” by which we pursue those ends. “The devil’s three temptations of Jesus all had to do with ways and means,” he wrote. “Every one of the devil’s goals was excellent. The devil had an unsurpassed vision statement. But the ways and means were incompatible with the ends.” (Letters to a Young Pastor by Eric E. Peterson)
Jesus did not debate the ethics or negotiate the terms; he simply rejected Satan’s premise with God’s truth: “Man does not live by bread alone.” It isn’t a slippery slope toward Satan’s goal; it is a gentle descent marked by seemingly reasonable decisions along the path.
Almost every day in ministry, we have an opportunity to take questionable steps. We can charge personal expenses to the church. We can use church discounts for personal purchases. We can round up attendance numbers. We can preach another pastor’s sermon.
The secular term for this is ethical fading, a process whereby the ethical part of a decision fades as we become focused on other factors like financial pressure, personal needs, or ambition. We think we are making ethical decisions, but our ethics have faded into the background. (Understanding Ethical Fading: An Invisible Corporate Culture Threat)
The reality is that who we are is revealed in private decisions long before public shame.
There are a few tests I’ve found helpful through the years:
The transparency test
- Could I explain this decision—and every reason behind it—to my elders, my spouse, and my congregation without leaving anything out?
- If this decision became public tomorrow, would I be comfortable defending it?
The wisdom test
- Is this wise?
- Does it build credibility?
- Does it strengthen trust?
The single mom test
I think about the single mom who faithfully gives to our church, even when money is tight.
- Would she believe this is a wise use of what she entrusted to God?
- Would I be comfortable explaining this expense to her children?
The identity test
- Does this decision reflect the person I want to become?
- Is this the legacy I want to leave?
- Will my grandchildren be proud of the decisions that shaped my life?
C. S. Lewis said, “Every time you make a choice you are turning the central part of you, the part of you that chooses, into something a little different than it was before.” (Mere Christianity by C. S. Lewis)
Day by day, decision by decision, am I becoming the person God created me to be?

Leave a Reply